It was a typical Saturday. I need to buy some used tires for a utility trailer to haul a tractor for mowing. I went to JMB Tire in Alvin, Texas because I've traded there for over 20 years. They didn't have used tires in the size I needed, so they recommend a few shops in Alvin, and suggested that there were several on Hwy 3. Lozano's Tire repair had one (1) tire, so I bought it from a young man there. He removed the old weather cracked tire from 1 of 5 wheels I brought with me, and showed me how rusty the bead area of the rim was. He took a small air powered steel brush, cleaned the rim, installed the tire, balanced it, checked for leaks in a water tank, and I was on my way. It was a complete transaction that had my satisfaction in mind. He checked his work in the tank before charging me.
Well, back to the Goodyear store in Alvin. I couldn't find 4 more used tires, and hate to have new ones rot off the trailer with full tread in a few years, but I had no choice but buy new ones. They wrote the ticket, and collected the tires from their inventory. Having just seen the condition of one rim, I suggested that they pull the old tires off, and I would take the rims home and clean them with a wire brush head on my welding grinder. The response was "We can do it for you." Well, that was good enough for me. I asked for a balance too, just like at Lazano's.
I picked up the tires in a couple of hours, and took them home. One tire was flat upon my arrival. I figured they forgot to air it up, so I filled it myself. An hour later it was flat again. JMB was closed by that time, and I needed the trailer the next day (including air in the tires). I took the tire off myself, carefully marking the orientation of the tire on the rim so as to preserve the balance when I re-installed it. The rim was filthy with loose rust and dirt. They had not cleaned the rim at JMB Tire, as promised. I brushed it as I had offered to do earlier in the day (while JMB was open), and filled it with air. It took 3 hours since I didn't have a tire machine. A couple of weeks later, 2 more of the 4 new tires were low on air. At least they held air long enough for a day trip to mow the land.
I took these 2 tires back to JMB and asked them to take the tires off so I could clean the rims. They did so with no consideration of the orientation of the tires on the rim, or even which tire came from which rim. The rims had the loose rust and dirt that I expected to see since the old weathered tires hadn't held air in a while. I took the rims home, brushed them well, and added a coat of teflon paste on the bead area for good measure. I wasn't terribly pleased to suffer this inconvenience, but everyone makes mistakes. I could forgive it if it was an oversight.
The same guy installed the tires this time as when I bought them, and was old enough that I would have expected him to understand the relationship between a clean bead area and the tire holding air, assuming holding air was a concern for him. He told me that nobody had asked him to clean the bean. I smiled (thinking.....you have to be told? as dirty as they were?) and suggested that he just didn't get the instructions, all while wondering why he didn't take the same professional care as the teenager at Lozano's.
We got along fine until his partner asked if the tires were to be balanced. He said "No". I pointed out that I paid for a balance a couple of weeks before and expected to leave with balanced tires. The partner started balancing them. Another guy suggested he hold off pending checking with the boss. I said "Balance the tires. I'll pay for it again if I have to. I'll not have tires bouncing all over the road when the trailer is empty." Sure enough, they charged me $15.00 for a second balancing. I told the man who has been in the office as long as I've been in Alvin that I didn't think it was right that I have to pay again for the same service. He said "We remounted them for you for free!" in a tone of voice like they did me a really big favor (3 hours on one tire, removal and return of 2 others, and two trips). I suggested that this favor would have been avoided if they had cleaned the rims as promised. He said "We don't clean rims." I said I just learned that, but he should "tell your staff not to say they do clean them when the customer offers to do it himself." He said "Did he prevent you from cleaning them?" I said "Yes, by telling me he would see that it was done instead of me doing it."
Well, in hindsight, lessons could have been learned if the business was interested in customer satisfaction. These are:
| 1. | Customers generally buy tires with expectation that they hold air. If they can't hold air because of the condition of the rim, then the customer should be warned that the transaction will not be successful. (Recall: I already told them that the rims needed cleaning, and offered to do it myself.) |
| 2. | Only hire staff who care about the customer's satisfaction with the product. (When the customer knows rims need a clean bead surface to hold air and the tire installer does not, you can expect problems with customer satisfaction.) |
| 3. | Don't assume the success of your business is soley based on transfer of ownership of tires and acceptance of payment. You are also selling "expertise" (assuming it exists). The most casual of observers knows that a tire purchaser has a right to expect the tire will hold air, and that the installer is responsible for verification of the integrity of his own work. The concept was understood by the young man at Lozano's, but lost on the " professionals" at my local Goodyear distributor. |
| 4. | When your shop makes a mistake such as declaring that it will provide a service that the customer offers to perform (knowing it is prerequisite for a successful transaction), and you don't provide it, you are morally responsible for the failure of the transaction that required that service. I knew the rims were going to need the brushing because I had seen one an hour before, and the young man at Lozano's recognized it was needed, even at his young age and limited experience. |
| 5. | When you charge a person for a service like a tire balancing, and your own omission or error negates the value of that service, then a refund is in order. I only thought I needed the tire balance because I though the tires were installed properly and would hold air. Had I realized that JMB Tire didn't care if the tires held air or not (Lozano's had an oval stock tank full of water for testing their installations.), I would have tested them myself before paying for the balancing. I actually sprayed the first tire with a mix of dish soap and water. Bubbles formed all around the rim on both sides of the tire because the bead couldn't seal until the rim was cleaned. |
I don't run Goodyear tires on my Bronco because they don't make one of the style I use. However, this year I bought 4 Goodyear garden tractor tires and 4 Goodyear tires for the trailor from JMB Tire in Alvin. They got their $15.00 after making it real plain to me that tires holding air was not a concern of theirs. They argue that it was my fault the rims were dirty, and it didn't matter that they prevented me from performing the necessary cleaning step by telling me they would do it.
I can't expect JMB Tire in Alvin, Texas to apply reasonable care and technical skills in their work on my vehicles.I even offered to perform the "slightly unusual" work (though apparently standard operating procedure at Lozano's) that I knew to be necessary to make their installation successful. In the future, I'll choose not to be responsible for their success, knowing that they do not consider holding air a necessary characteristic of a successful tire installation. They demonstrated that their reputation is of such little value that they would rather have $15 from me than admit an error.
Imagine this transaction....All this hassle, and the tires still have the blue coating on the whitewalls......
|